THE RESULTS!
As noted...this was a fair amount of work. You'll be removing your Rectifier and Filter Cap boards and enough wires to make you think you are going backwards for awhile But with my having already done the layout, planned the wiring and step-by-step plans here you should be able to knock it out in a few hours.
I have gone to the trouble of writing this all up for TWO reasons: 1) my amp NOW sounds incredibly better at very low volumes and 2) I want to make this mod as easy and as accessible as possible for others who think it seems too difficult (it isn't). This mod renders the long-awaited 5 watter SE Overtone unnecessary.
I realize that in citing my OPINIONS about something as subjective as "tone", I might be treading on sacred ground. I have no intention of starting a holy Dumble tone war. If I could actually play well I'd send clips but I refuse to be in the company of some of the people on this list. If you ever visit the Boston area let me know, you can have a test drive (bring an axe, I'm lefty).
Already, there are questions about whether the legendary Dumble circuit can be improved upon, that most of the tone is preamp generated and it doesn't need its power section driven hard etc...
Frankly, I don't have much love for pre-amp distortion. That's why I own THIS amp. To me, and I have the ears of a mortal only, pre-amp distortion sounds gritty and doesn't get me the smooth, bluesy/jazzy sustain and tone I want when cranked up... It's the Robben Ford, Larry Carlton etc fans who love this amp's tones and singing overdrive and sustain on the verge of feedback.
Stock 12AX7's sounded too gritty to my ears. And even with 12AX7's in V1 and V2, I needed to crank the amp to get the sustain and feedback I wanted. So I tried every combination of higher and lower gain tubes in the V1 and V2 positions. Ultimately I found that NOS 5751's in V1 and V2 took the edge off and created a mellower tone but I still couldn't overdrive the output section without ear-piercing volumes; same deal as with 12AX7's.
THE CONUNDRUM: Volume = tone.
I BELIEVE that the sweeter tones, sustain and namesake harmonic "overtones" of this amp come from an overdriven output section and not exclusively or even largely from the pre-amp section. If the pre-amp contained ALL of the magic, then I could simply turn down the MV and pretty much get the tone I wanted sans the compression, sustain and feedback but I could not. This is what led to the search for Iso cabs and attenuators.
SO WHAT DID I GET FOR MY EFFORTS?
Kevin O'Connor's SB-1 Power Scaling Kit definitely lives up to the promise. And for $80 USD
Check this out...with the Power Scale at 0% (max attenuation/minimum voltage & volume) I get bedroom level volumes (defined as being able to hear your hands and string/fretboard noises over the amp)
I can have my Preamp Volume at 1-2!, EQ at noon or PAB'd and the Power Amp section cranked up with MV at 6-10 (the incremental change in volume beyond 6 on the MV is not linear and increases only modestly). I get a beautiful overdrive I could NEVER get before at lower volumes. Finally, I have the tones everyone has been raving about with this amp. Because there is barely any noticeable "grit" and "distortion", the "overdrive" MUST be created by the output section with the Preamp volume at only 1-2.
Here is where is gets interesting:
Once you start to turn up just the pre-amp volume the distinguishable "grittier" distortion comes on and there is plenty on tap even with 5751's. Logically, I can only conclude that the output section DOES HAVE significant impact on the tone of this amp and unless you are cranking it up LOUD or using Power Scaling you aren't getting your money's worth.
I fell in love with this amp hearing all the great Ceriatone players. I didn't appreciate that an adequate environment to play it loud enough was necessary to really hear the tonal capabilities that sold me on it. Because it had MV I thought I could simply crank the MV way down and get most of the tone I wanted (I know you don't get the interaction with the speaker at VERY low volumes as you must push some air). Once it was built my ONLY disappointment was that it did sound beautiful when played loudly but I rarely have a chance to let a 50 watter run...my mistake but what's the alternative? A 20 watt Brown Note isn't much quieter.
I am strongly encouraging you guys to check out Kevin's Power Scaling. Even at gigging volumes it would have application when you are in smaller venues but still want the overdriven tone. For the more advanced tech's, this guy is a wealth of information and knowledge and has many more sophisticated mods that would afford even more control and possibilities.
Best of luck with your modding,
Matt